In a significant win for Florida State’s 2025 recruiting class, 5-star safety Trey McNutt, hailing from Galveston, Texas, announced his commitment to the Seminoles. McNutt, ranked as one of the top defensive players in the nation, chose Florida State over powerhouse programs such as Alabama, Michigan State, and his hometown team, Galveston University.
The decision solidifies Florida State’s continued resurgence under head coach Mike Norvell, who has transformed the Seminoles into a national contender both on the field and on the recruiting trail. Adding McNutt, a highly-touted prospect known for his elite athleticism, field awareness, and leadership, is a major coup that bolsters an already impressive 2025 class.
Why Florida State?
McNutt cited Florida State’s winning culture, player development, and coaching staff as key factors in his decision. “From the moment I visited Tallahassee, it felt like home,” McNutt said during his announcement. “Coach Norvell and Coach [insert defensive backs coach] showed me how I can grow both as a player and a person in their system. Florida State is building something special, and I want to be a part of it.”
The Seminoles’ success in producing NFL-caliber defensive backs also weighed heavily in McNutt’s choice. With a history of stars like Jalen Ramsey and Derwin James making waves at the next level, Florida State offers a proven pipeline to the pros.
The Player: What McNutt Brings to the Table
Standing 6-foot-2 and weighing 205 pounds, McNutt combines size, speed, and intelligence to dominate in the secondary. Known for his versatility, he excels in coverage, run support, and as a hard-hitting enforcer. His junior season at Galveston High showcased his ability to make game-changing plays, tallying six interceptions, 80 tackles, and two forced fumbles while leading his team deep into the state playoffs.
Recruiting analysts have praised McNutt as a “day-one impact player,” noting his instincts and ability to anticipate plays before they develop. His physical tools, paired with an advanced football IQ, make him a rare find and a potential cornerstone of Florida State’s defense.
Beating the Competition
McNutt’s recruitment was one of the most hotly contested battles in the 2025 cycle. Alabama, Michigan State, and Galveston University all made strong pushes for the safety, offering him the opportunity to be a centerpiece of their respective defenses. Alabama’s tradition of defensive dominance, Michigan State’s rising momentum under [head coach’s name], and Galveston’s hometown appeal made McNutt’s decision anything but easy.
In the end, however, Florida State’s combination of tradition, player development, and personal connection won out. “It was a tough decision because every school had something unique to offer,” McNutt admitted. “But Florida State gave me the best overall fit.”
A Bright Future in Tallahassee
Trey McNutt’s commitment marks a pivotal moment for Florida State, as they continue to stack talent and position themselves as a perennial contender in college football. For McNutt, the decision to join the Seminoles is just the beginning. With his blend of skills and work ethic, he has all the tools to become the next great safety to don the garnet and gold.
Florida State fans can look forward to McNutt making an immediate impact in the 2025 season, as he looks to anchor a defense poised for greatness. For now, Seminole Nation can celebrate landing one of the top players in the country and dream of the bright future ahead.
