Ohio State continues to cement its reputation as a powerhouse in college football recruiting, securing a major win with the commitment of Trey McNutt, a 5-star safety from Ball High School in Galveston, Texas. McNutt, ranked as one of the top defensive prospects in the 2025 recruiting class, chose the Buckeyes over strong competition from Indiana, Michigan State, and perennial SEC contender Alabama.
A Big Win for the Buckeyes
McNutt’s commitment is a massive boost for Ohio State, who has been on a recruiting roll under head coach Ryan Day. Known for producing NFL-caliber defensive backs, Ohio State’s pitch clearly resonated with McNutt, who cited the program’s winning culture, player development, and defensive schemes as major reasons for his decision.
“Ohio State felt like home from the start,” McNutt said in an announcement on social media. “The coaches, the fans, and the entire program made me feel like I belonged. I’m excited to be a part of something special in Columbus.”
What McNutt Brings to the Table
Standing 6’2” and weighing 195 pounds, McNutt is a physical and versatile safety who can excel in both pass coverage and run support. His instincts, range, and ability to read offenses make him a nightmare for opposing quarterbacks. In his junior season at Ball High School, McNutt recorded 82 tackles, five interceptions, and two forced fumbles, earning him a spot on the Texas All-State First Team.
McNutt’s athleticism also makes him a threat in the return game, where he showcased his explosive playmaking ability with two punt return touchdowns last season. His rare combination of size, speed, and football IQ has drawn comparisons to NFL stars like Derwin James and Minkah Fitzpatrick.
Turning Down Top Contenders
Ohio State wasn’t the only program making a strong push for McNutt. Indiana and Michigan State both heavily recruited the star safety, hoping to make him a centerpiece of their rebuilding efforts. Alabama, known for dominating the recruiting trail, was also in the mix, but ultimately, the Buckeyes’ blend of tradition and player development won out.
Ohio State’s 2025 Class: A Look Ahead
With McNutt’s commitment, Ohio State’s 2025 recruiting class continues to look like one of the nation’s best. He joins a group already loaded with elite talent on both sides of the ball, further solidifying Ohio State’s status as a perennial College Football Playoff contender.
For the Buckeyes, McNutt’s pledge is more than just a recruiting victory — it’s a signal that Ohio State remains a destination program for the country’s top athletes. And for McNutt, the next chapter of his football journey will be written in Columbus, where he’ll aim to leave a legacy as one of the best safeties in Buckeye history.
Ohio State fans have every reason to celebrate as the Buckeyes prepare to welcome a game-changing talent into their fold.
